UDC 550.93 : 551.00/.72

L.M. Stepanyuk
M.P. Semenenko Institute of Geochemistry, Mineralogy and Ore Formation of the NAS of Ukraine. 34, Acad. Palladin Ave., Kyiv, Ukraine, 03142

SOME CRITICAL NOTES ON ARTICLE Kyrylyuk V.P., Bogdanova M.I., Savina E.I. "Petroparageneses and Possible Origin of the Bug Area Granulite Complex Supercrustal Formations (Western Part of Ukrainian Shield)". Article 1. "General Information and Rock Composition of the Petroparageneses"

Language: Ukrainian
Mineralogical journal 2019, 41 (1): 71-73

Some remark sabout basic concepts mentioned in paper title are made. In particular, possible identification of geological sections made on results of field evidences with stratigraphic sections is denied, that is based on the presence of intrusive bodies of metamorphosed magmatic rocks, frequently metasomatites, within geological sections of highly-metamorphosed associations.In addition, the alternative view on fundamental basis of petroparageneses substantiation i expressed. Namely, the term paragenetic is proposed to be applied for of rocks which are not only occur close lybutare formed simultaneously.
Keywords: petrotypes of rocks, stratigraphic subdivisions, critical remarks.


  1. Kyrylyuk, V.P. (2017), Geol. zhurn., No. 4, Kyiv, UA, pp. 88-99.
  2. Kryvdik, S.G., Kravchenko, G.L., Tomurko, L.L., Dubyna, O.V., Zagnitko, B.M., Rokachuk, T.A., Schnyukova, K.Ye. and Mineyeva, V.M. (2011), Petrologiia i geochimiia charnokitoyidiv Ukrainskogo shchyta, Nauk. dumka, Kyiv, UA, 216 p.
  3. Lazko, E.M., Kyrylyuk, V.P., Sivoronov, A.A. and Yatsenko, G.M. (1975), Lower Precambrian of the western Ukrainian Shield (age complexes and formations), Vyshcha shkola, Lviv, UA, 239 p.
  4. Ponomarenko, A.N., Gintov, O.B. and Stepanyuk, L.M. (2018), Geophysical journ., Vol. 40, No. 5, Kyiv, UA, pp. 47-70.
  5. Stepanyuk, L.M. (2018), Mineral. Journ. (Ukraine), Vol. 40, No. 1, Kyiv, UA, pp. 16-31.
  6. Stepanyuk, L.M., Kotvitska, I.M., Andreev, A.V., Kurylo, S.I. and Grinchenko, O.V. (2018), Mineral. Journ. (Ukraine), Vol. 40, No. 4, Kyiv, UA, pp. 79-88.